Challenging Views on Sobriety: My Five Controversial Opinions
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to Controversial Sobriety Opinions
Prepare yourself for some disagreements!
Photo by Toa Heftiba on Unsplash
Having spent over ten years struggling with alcohol, I am proud to say I have maintained sobriety for five and a half years. Generally, I identify as a typical recovering addict, aligning with much of the common wisdom on sobriety, such as “taking it one day at a time” and “finding your support network.”
Nevertheless, I hold several views about sobriety that diverge from the mainstream, and I’m eager to share them. A word of caution: you might find yourself disagreeing with some, if not all, of these perspectives. That’s precisely the intent of this article! I encourage respectful dialogue in the comments, but I have no tolerance for disrespect. Rude or condescending remarks will be deleted.
So, without further delay, here are my five most contentious views on sobriety:
Section 1.1: Contingency Management Is Effective
What if we incentivized sobriety? At first glance, the notion of paying addicts to remain sober seems absurd. My personal experience with addiction made me skeptical—after years of battling alcoholism and nicotine dependence, I struggled to see how monetary rewards could influence someone’s ability to resist substance abuse.
However, research supports this approach. A recent meta-analysis revealed that contingency management yields remarkable outcomes. It turns out that providing financial incentives for maintaining sobriety can significantly impact recovery rates, regardless of my initial skepticism. Furthermore, it’s a cost-effective strategy, as even small payments can encourage lasting change.
Section 1.2: The Debate on "California Sober"
One of the most hotly debated topics in recovery circles is the concept of being “California sober.” This term, gaining attention thanks to various celebrities, generally means abstaining from alcohol and hard drugs while still using cannabis.
While I used to smoke pot occasionally without issues, I ultimately decided it was not compatible with my sobriety. After attempting to reintroduce it into my life post-alcohol, I realized I was merely substituting one substance for another. However, many individuals maintain a California sober lifestyle successfully, and I respect their choices, even if it doesn’t work for me.
Subsection 1.2.1: Does Pot Compromise Sobriety?
Where I draw my personal boundaries in sobriety.
Section 1.3: A Balanced View on Alcoholics Anonymous
Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) is another divisive topic within recovery discussions. While AA has been pivotal for many, others view it as outdated or even cult-like. Personally, I find AA to be beneficial, but it wasn’t the sole path to my recovery.
I attended numerous AA meetings but never engaged deeply with the program. I didn’t have a sponsor or actively work the steps; instead, I absorbed knowledge and support from fellow attendees. Even without fully committing to AA, it played a crucial role in my journey toward sobriety.
Section 1.4: Non-Alcoholic Beers: A Personal Choice
This opinion may stir the most debate: I believe it’s acceptable for recovering alcoholics to consume non-alcoholic beers. Despite the adage that “non-alcoholic beers are for non-alcoholics,” I’ve encountered many who found them helpful in their recovery.
Initially, I avoided non-alcoholic beer for fear of triggering cravings. However, after five years of sobriety, I tried one at a gathering and found it harmless. I’ve received backlash for this perspective, with some claiming it risks relapse, while others argue it constitutes one. I maintain that for some, these beverages can be a safe option in recovery.
Section 1.5: Not Everyone Needs to Quit Completely
Finally, I assert that not all heavy drinkers must attain complete sobriety. Some individuals can learn to drink moderately. My attempts to moderate my drinking were futile, ultimately leading to my decision to quit entirely.
However, I’ve heard stories of others who have successfully moderated their drinking habits. The challenge lies in identifying whether moderation is a feasible option for each person, which often involves a lengthy, trial-and-error process.
In conclusion, I invite your thoughts on these controversial opinions. Do any resonate with you? Are there disagreements? Please share your insights in the comments, but let’s keep it respectful. Thank you for reading!
About the Author:
I’m Benya Clark, a former lawyer turned writer focusing on addiction, mental health, and recovery. Don’t forget to check out my weekly newsletter featuring essays on sobriety.