# Tommy Shelby: A Complex Anti-Hero Redefining Morality in TV
Written on
Chapter 1: The Unconventional Anti-Hero
Tommy Shelby consistently strives to improve himself, even as he grapples with his dark past.
“I’m just like you now, you and Arthur. I was dead in that noose, and then I was saved. So everything from now on is extra. What I didn’t understand until today is when you’re dead already, you’re free.” — Aunt Polly to Tommy Shelby
In contrast to the overtly bold personas of characters like Don Draper, Walter White, and Tony Soprano, Tommy Shelby operates with a more subtle intelligence, orchestrating events from the shadows. Each of these figures is influenced by their own unique burdens.
Don Draper is haunted by his past traumas and a longing for an unattainable identity. Walter White, facing terminal cancer, seeks a sense of power in the criminal underworld, while Tony Soprano is simply entrenched in the family business.
But what fuels Tommy Shelby’s relentless ambition? What compels him to maintain his dominance over Birmingham’s streets?
While it’s tempting to suggest that Tommy’s motivations stem from his family legacy, it’s clear that, as the second oldest sibling, he had the option to step back, potentially following his youthful ideals of communism.
The character most similar to Tommy is Tony Soprano. Both grapple with psychological scars—Tommy from his World War I experiences and Tony from the stress of his mob life.
Section 1.1: The Reluctant Leader
Tommy Shelby is not merely a passive leader; his intellect and capability surpass that of his older brother, pushing him into a role he didn’t have to take. Unlike the other anti-heroes, Tommy’s Romani heritage and working-class background inform his understanding that British high society will never fully accept him or his family.
Time and again, Tommy attempts to legitimize his family’s business, but he ultimately concludes that crime and vice are all they have. His motivations are not solely rooted in duty but also in a sense of resignation—he has no viable alternatives after stepping into power.
This inability to retreat mirrors the journeys of other anti-heroes; once they venture into darkness, reversing course becomes impossible. For instance, Don Draper cannot reclaim his former identity after adopting a deceased superior’s life, and Walter White is unable to stop his meth production once he begins.
Chapter 2: The Weight of Ambition
The first video, "Why Do We Enjoy Watching an ANTI HERO like Thomas Shelby?" delves into the audience's fascination with complex characters like Tommy Shelby, exploring the psychological and moral dilemmas they face.
Tommy Shelby’s involvement in politics sets him apart from his counterparts. A World War I veteran and a war hero, he bears the psychological scars of battle, which desensitize him to the violence he orchestrates. In later seasons of Peaky Blinders, he even engages in the fight against fascism, albeit with dire repercussions, including the loss of family members.
Section 2.1: The Consequences of Overreaching
Critics often label Tommy as overly ambitious, claiming that this drives his numerous enemies. He embodies a complex character—capable of heinous acts while simultaneously striving to do what’s right. In reality, his family would likely be viewed as despicable criminals, indifferent to the lives they take.
Yet, beneath Tommy’s ruthless exterior lies a man in profound pain, who feels as though he survived the war by sheer luck. Life, for him, becomes merely a series of motions, devoid of joy.
The tragedy of Tommy Shelby is that he yearns for death. He derives no pleasure from living and often resorts to destructive behaviors to find purpose. When confronted with his trauma, he succumbs to his vices, revealing his struggle to cope.
The second video, "The Ruthless Nature Of Thomas Shelby - Character Analysis (Part 1)," offers a deeper look into Tommy’s character, emphasizing his moral dilemmas and the complexities that make him both compelling and tragic.
Section 2.2: The Search for Morality
Despite his violent actions, Tommy attempts to adhere to a moral compass, especially in the later seasons as he battles fascism. However, the contradiction between his actions and his self-perception often leaves him in moral conflict.
When his son is kidnapped, Tommy confronts Alfie Solomons, demanding accountability for crossing a moral line. In response, Solomons challenges Tommy’s own history of violence, highlighting the hypocrisy in his quest for moral superiority.
Ultimately, Tommy Shelby embodies the flawed human condition, where lofty ideals clash with reality. While he continues to commit horrific acts, he also strives for redemption. Unlike his fellow anti-heroes, Tommy’s repeated attempts to improve himself make him a uniquely intriguing character.
In the end, Tommy Shelby stands as a testament to the complexity of human nature. While he may not always succeed in his quest for goodness, his persistent efforts render him a compelling figure, one who resonates with the shared struggles within us all.